






|
|
June 2005 Jerusalem photos
We
visited Jerusalem twice, once with Jessica Burshell and once with
Carol Robinson. Both times, our first stop was on the outskirts
of New Jerusalem, to see the Dead Sea scrolls at the Israel Museum.
To our disappointment, the Shrine of the Book shows only a small
portion of one of the original scrolls (the rest of the scrolls
on display being facsimiles). The display is still impressive, and
the story of the discovery and preservation is almost as compelling
as the stories in the scrolls. It involves a shepherd boy who threw
a rock into a cave, various scheming antiquities dealers, the outbreak
of the 1948 War of Independence, and lots of cloak and dagger stuff.
The historical significance of the scrolls is that they are the
oldest known Hebrew version of the Bible. The only Jewish religious
tracts that pre-date the Dead Sea Scrolls are in Greek, the written
language of the Middle East from the time of Alexander until the
Middle Ages.
Actually, more impressive than the
Israel Museum in terms of historical perspective was the Bible Lands
Museum right across the street, where we spent several hours on
each of our two trips. Despite the vaguely religious sound of its
name, Bible Lands is not at all religious, or even particularly
Judeo-centric. It has an incredible wealth of archeological finds
from all over Israel, Jordan and Egypt, with extremely thorough
and erudite explanations in English as well as Hebrew. We learned
a lot about the history of writing, of seals and signatures, burial
rites, architecture, wars and migrations in the Middle East, from
the dawn of history to the Diaspora. Later, when we visited Egypt,
we were really glad we had seen the displays and descriptions of
the Pyramids in the Bible Lands Museum, which explained things much
better than anything available at Giza!
For both of our Jerusalem visits
we had lodgings in the Old City, which is still surrounded by high
walls, built by Suleyman the Magnificent in the 16th Century. While
one can drive into parts of it, most of it is inaccessible to cars,
being narrow covered streets with steps, so we left our rental car
in a garage just outside the Jaffa Gates near where we stayed. When
we were with Jess, we stayed at a Maronite Christian convent, in
simple small rooms around a lovely peaceful courtyard. On our second
trip, with Carol, we stayed at the funky Imperial Hotel. It dates
from the 19th century and is where Kaiser Wilhelm once stayed. Its
grandeur is definitely faded by now, but we were hooked when we
found that Selma Lagerlof had spent time there. (She's the author
of "The Wonderful Adventures of Nils," whence Akka got
her name.) The Imperial proved as noisy as the convent had been
peaceful, but it was all a good adventure.
On both trips first "must-see" in
the Old City was the Western (or Wailing) Wall, the holiest of Jewish
sites. It is the last remaining vestige of the Second Temple, which
was destroyed in 70 AD. Since taking over Jerusalem in 1967, Israel
has cleared an enormous plaza in front of the Western Wall. Extraordinarily
tight security is enforced to enter this plaza, with metal detectors
and 4-5 armed uniformed personnel to check all bags. About 2/3 of
the way toward the Wall, a fence separates spectators from the worshippers;
then, inside that fence, there's another fence perpendicular to
the Wall that separates the men's area from the women's. The women
only get about 1/3 of the Wall; we understand that the women's share
of the wall has been decreased over the years as ultra-Orthodox
groups exert their influence. From inside the men's area there is
access to a tunnel that goes under the buildings on that side of
the square. Rob went into the tunnel, to find a library and lots
more men reading and praying. We went to the plaza by the Wall several
times, and we'd say there were generally around 200 men and women
in the prayer enclosure, on average. Black and white predominated
as the clothing colors of choice. One time, we saw a number of boys
being escorted into the enclosure by singing men; it turns out they
were having their bar mitzvahs. The boys' female relatives who wanted
to watch had to bring chairs into the women's enclosure and stand
precariously on them, so they could see over the barricade. Interestingly,
the boys were not dressed up, but wore t-shirts and jeans - unusually
informal wear even for the Old City in general, let alone at the
Wall. Later, as we ascended the ramp to the Temple Mount, we noticed
a group holding what looked like another bar mitzvah, in the archaeological
excavations spanned by the ramp. The Wall continues over there,
though we're not sure if this is still the wall of the old Temple
or simply part of the retaining wall for Temple Mount. Anyway, there
were both men and women in attendance at this separate ceremony.
Maybe Reform Jews? Next must-see: the Temple Mount or Haram esh-Sharif,
the third most holy site of Islam (after Mecca and Medina). Access
to the Temple Mount is via a rather crude covered wooden ramp off
to one side of the Western Wall. Although we'd already gone through
tight security to enter the Wall plaza, there was another equally
thorough security check at the ramp, as well as armed guards on
the plaza of Temple Mount itself.
The Temple Mount plateau is the
site of several of Islam's most holy places, including the Al-Aqsa
Mosque, from which Mohammed ascended into heaven (for one night,
just a preliminary visit, really) and the stunning Dome of the Rock,
whose gilt dome dominates the Jerusalem skyline. The Rock (in the
center of the Dome) is said to be the site where Abraham was asked
to sacrifice Isaac. The dome is covered in real gold leaf, provided
by Jordan's late King Hussein to replace the ugly fake gold, which
replaced the original copper, which had been removed to make cannon.
It's said Hussein sold a house in London to pay for the gold. It
was worth it: the Dome is magnificent, as is the plaza that makes
up the Temple Mount. It's geometric, with symmetric sets of steps
and colonnades leading to the Dome of the Rock. The majestic Dome
tops a stunning building decorated with blue tiles of cursive Arabic
script praising Allah, leaded windows, carved and gilded doors.
Alas, as non-Muslims we were forbidden entry to it, and to the Al-Aqsa
mosque, by armed Israeli guards. (There was some disagreement amongst
people we talked to about the legitimacy of this. Our Palestinian
hosts at the Imperial Hotel insisted that we were allowed to enter
the Dome of the Rock, at least - that's not a mosque, so there are
no prayers to interrupt. On the other hand, some cruising friends
were chased away from the door by Muslims shouting "Infidel
Americans, go away.") Just outside of the Dome of the Rock
is a smaller dome - the Dome of the Chain - a sort of open air mosque
with slender columns and a beautiful tiled ceiling, said to be more
magnificent than that in the Dome of the Rock. It's also said to
be the center of the world
The third standard "must see"
in Jerusalem is the Church of the Holy Sepulchre - so off we went
to see it. It's one of the holiest sites in Christendom. The church
stands on the very spot where Christ was crucified, buried, and
resurrected, and fortuitously also the site where Adam's skull was
buried. It also contains the place where the Holy Cross was hidden
for some 400 years before being rediscovered by St. Helen, mother
of Emperor Constantine. And, it's said to be the center of the world
(sound familiar?) Ancient maps were centered on Jerusalem, and a
stone basin inside the church marks the very center. The church
itself is a gloomy, somewhat deteriorating edifice, with very little
signage to indicate what is what. The building is "owned"
jointly by six different Christian sects: the Armenian, Greek Orthodox,
Syrian, Coptic, Roman Catholic and Ethiopian churches. Each sect's
roles and privileges are guarded jealously, to the extent that none
will allow any of the others to open the church in the morning and
lock it at night - that job has been performed for centuries by
members of the same Muslim family, who are of course "neutral
parties". The division of areas to the different sects, and
their rights to conduct ceremonies and carry out maintenance, were
determined by an Ottoman decree of 1850. According to that decree,
if one of the sects repairs a previously unspoken-for part of the
church, the repairer gains "ownership" of that part. This
leads all the sects to obstruct any repairs by the other sects,
except in the repairer's own limited area. As a result, parts of
the church are literally falling down; some years ago, the Roman
Catholics replaced three of the six pillars supporting the dome
of the church's main rotunda, but were prevented by the other sects
from replacing the other three, which are visibly crumbling. We
found the church interesting and in places beautiful, but the real
impact comes from being at the site of all the events of Christ's
crucifixion, and for us at least, that impact was dulled by all
the gloppy (and somewhat shabby) embellishments that have been added
through the years. For example, Christ's tomb was a cave in a rock,
not an ornate little chapel inside a huge domed basilica, and to
the extent that one can't see the cave (the entire hill was leveled
by Constantine to build the first church on the site), one misses
the point.
An interesting side note was the
almost total lack of security at the Church of the Holy Sepuchre.
In contrast to the metal detectors, wands and armed service personnel
at the most holy sites of Islam and Judaism, there were rent-a-cops
here, with the same security as a shopping mall. Guess we know where
the conflicts lie. (Or maybe it's another illustration of the bickering
for control among the sects who govern the Church.)
Of course, we spent a fair amount
of time simply wandering around in the Old City. It has four sections:
Greek Orthodox, Arab, Jewish and Armenian. No walls divide these,
but each has its own character and flavor. Religious buildings are
scattered everywhere. Unlike other Middle Eastern cities we've visited,
Jerusalem doesn't have a bazaar or souk per se. Rather, most of
the city streets form a huge bazaar. Parts are covered by domed
roofs or rattan screens, others are open streets. Where the streets
slope, there are wide shallow steps on either side, but the center
is open for the push-carts which deliver goods around. These, generally
"manned" by adolescent boys (we never could figure out
how, if and when they went to school), have an ingenious "brake."
There's a spare tire chained to the back of the cart. When the cart
needs to be slowed, the kid tosses the tire to the pavement and
steps on it. Unlike other places we'd been, like Istanbul and Damascus,
where everybody in the bazaar is at least a potential customer (why
else is he there?), in Jerusalem most of the people walking past
the shops and stands of the bazaar are simply on their way somewhere
else. This makes the vendors a little less insistent and perhaps
a little more inventive. Our favorite of the many Jerusalem come-ons
was "Is there any chance I can get you into my shop and rip
you off?" Well, at least it's honest.
We did discover one way to get shop
owners and street vendors to stop importuning us: we simply asked
directions to our destination (or, if we had no destination, to
somewhere in the general direction we were headed). Invariably,
the would-be merchant immediately turned into a tour guide. "Oh,
that's easy," he says, "You continue this way until the
end, then turn right, then take your first left - that'll lead you
right to it." Shalom.
The one sight that is unique to
Jerusalem's Old City streets is the groups of Christian pilgrims
following the Via Dolorosa, the path taken by Christ to his crucifixion.
This holy route winds through the city, primarily through the Muslim
quarter. There are 14 "stations of the cross" where certain
events in the crucifixion supposedly occurred (according to scholars,
at least 2 are almost certainly in the wrong places), each marked
by a wall plaque. Pilgrims regularly follow this walk, often carrying
a replica cross. (These can be rented at the start of the Via Dolorosa,
and it's fun to see the boys dashing back from the Church of the
Holy Sepulchre, carrying the crosses back.) The pilgrims stop at
each station, recite prayers, switch cross-bearers, and move on.
We saw a group of African pilgrims, dressed all in white, who sang
beautifully the entire way. The pilgrims are interspersed with tour
groups following the same route but with considerably less fervor.
Several of these groups had machine gun toting escorts.
We were endlessly fascinated by
the incredible variety of people we saw in Jerusalem's streets.
While the old city is traditionally divided into Muslim, Christian,
Jewish and Armenian sectors, each of which has a different flavor,
in the streets of the bazaar everyone rubs shoulders. There are
Palestinian women in traditional long black dresses with embroidered
bodices and full head coverings (some carrying baskets or bags on
their heads), modern teens in jeans and long blouses (no women in
the Old City bare their arms or legs), orthodox Jews in log black
coats with full beards and long hair topped by black felt hats,
a few women in complete chadors, business men in suits - the Jews
marked by tiny kippahs clipped to their short hair, kids in every
bright outfit imaginable, Druze men in white or tan gelabbeyahs
with white skullcaps, women in a variety of somber-colored long
robes, some with beautiful embroidery or sequins, wearing many different
colors of headscarves, and, of course, the tourists in their tan
pants, plaid shirts, running shoes, floppy hat or baseball caps,
and cameras. What a kaleidoscope!
The last day we were in Jerusalem
with Jessica, we had an experience that isn't in the guide books,
but which we found so moving that we went back to experience it
again when Carol came to visit. We had read that the Armenian Church
of St. James was one of the most beautiful churches, architecturally,
in the city. Unfortunately it was only open during services, from
6 to 7 AM and from 4 to 5 PM each day. Because we were planning
to leave in mid-morning, the afternoon times were out of the question;
so the two of us got up at 6:00 (leaving Jess in bed) and walked
the 4 blocks to St. James's.
On the door of the church was a
notice asking visitors to respect the church, not move around during
the service, and not cross their legs when they sat. We entered
mid-service and found a company of perhaps 40 monks in prayer. Dressed
in dark brown medieval robes with pointed hoods that totally hid
their faces, they were chanting the liturgy, presumably in Armenian
and definitely in some non-standard modality. Dim sunlight from
the high windows filtered through the incense, but the church was
also illuminated by scores of candles and oil lamps. The interior
is beautiful, completely tiled in blue and white, with huge paintings
almost too darkened by time (and soot) to make out, and two golden
thrones near the altar: one for the patriarch and one said to be
for St. James the Less (not to be confused with St. James the Great,
over whose tomb the church was built), which is only used once a
year. We sat (uncross-legged) in the benches at the rear wall -
the rest of the church has no seats, only oriental carpets fully
covering the floor --listened and watched in fascination, transported
in a moment back a thousand years. Eventually (and not before the
bench seats had impressed their hardness upon us) the monks all
filed out into the courtyard, where many were revealed to be mere
boys, who, after shucking their robes, wore the blazers and ties
of a private school. Sure enough, off they marched across the street
to the Armenian seminary, for their daily lessons. And off we went
for a cup of coffee.
Hungry for lunch one day, Jess,
Andi and Rob set off through the bazaar looking for a falafel stand.
The only ones we found were stand-up places, and we were foot-sore
enough to want to sit down to eat. Eventually, we found ourselves
near the Damascus Gate, deep in the Arab quarter. We turned right,
and about 100 meters along the street we saw a pizza place. Well,
we thought, why not? We'd tried Armenian pizza and liked it; why
not Arab pizza? As it turned out, both the pizza and the welcome
were outstanding. We noticed, across the street, one of the plaques
for the Via Dolorosa. We mentioned this to the proprietor and asked
him which Station of the Cross this was. He replied with a straight
face, "It's where Christ had pizza." We weren't sure whether
to laugh or be embarrassed by his sacrilege, and we guess our dilemma
showed on our faces. "No, really," he said. "Every
year there's a pageant at Easter, and the guy who plays Christ in
the pageant? He eats here."
We liked the pizza and the proprietor
so much that we brought Carol to the same place. This time we elected
to eat inside instead of on the street, where it was quite hot.
The pizza was great, as before. Looking around the interior, we
noticed a number of beautiful carpets hung around the walls. When
we inquired about them, the owner told us they were pure silk, from
Persia (Iran) and came from his brother's store. In fact, he said,
if we wanted to look at some more rugs like these, he could take
us there, no obligation of course
But that's another story.
(See our photos accompanying
this Adventure)
.
|